A sample text widget

Etiam pulvinar consectetur dolor sed malesuada. Ut convallis euismod dolor nec pretium. Nunc ut tristique massa.

Nam sodales mi vitae dolor ullamcorper et vulputate enim accumsan. Morbi orci magna, tincidunt vitae molestie nec, molestie at mi. Nulla nulla lorem, suscipit in posuere in, interdum non magna.

Point/Counterpoint: Does financial news matter?

Warren Ingram CFP South Africa

Warren Ingram, CFP says financial news is noise:

It might seem strange for a person who appears regularly in the media to to state that financial news is noise. I feel that very little financial reporting contains valuable information. Real-time financial news actually inhibits good financial decision-making. Most investors would be better off if they ignored financial news.

Financial Hype

If you follow financial news in real time i.e. on TV, radio or the internet, you are most likely getting sound bites designed to grab your attention. This means you are being fed dramatic headlines and stories filled with vivid descriptions of what happened in the markets 10 minutes ago. This is the financial equivalent of consuming coffee via a drip injection. It will get your heart racing but it is definitely bad for your health.

Any external event that is so significant that it will affect your financial position is likely to happen so suddenly that you will not be able to react to it until it is too late. For example, if there is another terrorist attack that closes down Wall Street, the damage would have been done before you have time to react. Less dramatic events like the publication of a country’s inflation data will get a lot of airtime from the media. However this information is only marginally relevant to your long-term investments. As Warren Buffett said in his last shareholder’s meeting, he has never made an investment based on economic forecasts, if he does not worry about this, why should we?

What to Read Instead

Personally, I have tried to insulate myself from market noise by avoiding all daily broadcasts and publications of financial news. I only read the headlines of one daily business publication to ensure that I am aware of any major market-moving event. By this I mean an earth quake, assassination of a political leader or terrorist attack, not minor events like a speech by a politician. I obtain my financial information through a range of periodical publications and investment journals as these provide a better perspective on what is happening in the world. I started this habit five years ago and while it was quite daunting in the beginning, I found that my financial decision making actually improved. During the Global Financial Crisis I was able to maintain a relatively even keel despite the dramatic events that were taking place around the world. This proved valuable when I was talking to clients because I was able to give them perspective.

It is obvious that market traders need access to real-time information. However long-term investors (including professionals) might be better off limiting their intake of daily financial news. In my view, valuable investment information is most often obtained in periodical journals, books, lectures and discussions with seasoned professionals. It is far better to read about investment principles and long-term demographic trends than it is to be updated on the latest price movements of shares, commodities and currencies.

Create Your Own Bubble

I feel that the best way to make sound financial decisions in all stock market conditions is to build a financial game plan that does not rely on predictions, forecasts or short-term fluctuations. Your game plan should be built on factors that you control i.e. your assets, debts, income, expenses and objectives. You cannot control stock market fluctuations so ensure that your planning caters for rising and falling markets. By doing this, you will be able to use your plan as your anchor for making sound decisions. This will make life a lot more relaxed for you and will enable you to cut out the financial noise.

Willie Yiu, AFP says financial news is noise but it can be a big deal to clients:

Having grown up in, studied and worked in Australia – an environment with sophisticated systems in regulation, tax and estate duties, social security and retirement benefits – most understand that professional guidance is needed to navigate through the various complex issues. Basic financial literacy concepts such as financial news being noise was a common understanding in the community.

To illustrate, when clients in Australia experience a market adjustment – many would seek guidance from their advisers before taking action (if any) with their portfolio. In addition, the time and costs (transactions and taxes) attached to each financial decision through the aforementioned systems almost demands that one must think and plan carefully before execution, with or without a planner by your side. It was something I accepted as the norm and did not really question.

Cultural Differences

Imagine my culture shock upon returning to work in Hong Kong, a very fast paced environment where the general approach to its systems is to keep things simple. The time, cost and taxes involved in making an investment decision is kept at a minimum and at times there is none at all! (There is no CGT in Hong Kong). As such, many individual investors happily and frequently engage in finding that next investment opportunity to reap a nice profit! Financial news is often greeted with the opportunistic thinking “Can I make something out of it?” instead of being considered as noise. Adviser attempts to convince clients in Hong Kong that news is noise would often be met with scepticism. With low transaction costs and little to no systematic issues to consider, many believe in and make use of the greater fool concept for a quick profit. This belief can often be seen in public with people from all walks of life standing in front of trading screens of banks and investment platform providers. Given the sheer volume of daily transactions, there are many who can capitalise on their gains and pull out before the market adjusts itself. Whether they could do this consistently is another issue, many investors agree with me that they could not achieve profits to be equal or greater than their annual income and benefits.

As Warren stated, the problem with financial news is that it is basically designed to grab attention. I would like to expand on this and say that financial news is noise because it carries an underlying call to action but does not take account of the individual’s situation.

Benefits of Financial Planning

The great thing about financial planning is that it introduces a systematic approach to understanding one’s goals, needs and wants before quantifying their ability to achieve it all with a detailed analysis on one’s current and future financial capabilities. The Hong Kong public is beginning to see the value of professional advice with the market volatility since 2008 combined with regulatory changes, regulator and financial institution media campaigns advising investors to give due consideration before making an investment decision.

Whilst the noise can be a distraction, it offers planners a chance to strengthen their client-planner relationship and potentially bring in new opportunities.

Leave a Reply

You can use these HTML tags

<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>